A Sight For Sore Eyes – Scarlett Rose & Selina Bentz

Title: “A Sight For Sore Eyes: The Naughty Step Fantasy Unleashed”

Penny returned home from another grueling day at the office, exhausted and eager to shed her stifling business attire. She kicked off her heels and wiggled out of her pencil skirt and blouse, sighing in relief as the fabric slid away from her sun-kissed skin.

Padding barefoot into the living room, Penny gasped. There on the couch sat her stepbrother, Jack, nursing a beer and flipping through channels. His eyes roamed hungrily over Penny’s barely-there lingerie and she felt a thrill run through her.

“L-lost my key,” Jack stammered, unable to tear his gaze away from her heaving bosom. “Guess I’m crashing here tonight.”

Penny smirked, crossing the room. “Oh, I don’t know,” she purred, straddling his lap. “This old couch isn’t very big. We might have to get cozy.”

She could feel Jack’s hardness pressing insistently against her barely-covered sex through his jeans. Her nipples stiffened, poking against the thin lace of her bra. Lowering her mouth to his ear, Penny whispered, “Promise me you’ll be a good boy?”

Jack groaned, his hands settling on her hips. “I don’t know if I can promise that.”

Penny giggled and ground against him to tease, then stood and crooked a finger. “C’mon, then. Let’s find you a bed.”

She led him to her room, closing the door behind them. As Jack flopped onto her unmade bed, Penny reached back to unclasp her bra. She let it fall to the floor, revealing small, pert breasts topped with rosy nipples, already puckered in the cool air.

Jack’s eyes nearly bugged out of his head as he drank in the sight of his sexy step-sis topless before him. “Jesus, Penny…”

She shimmied out of her panties next, turning away from him and bending at the waist to slip the lace down her long legs. Penny looked back at him over her shoulder, biting her plump bottom lip. “Like the view?” She wiggled her shapely ass.

Jack’s mouth went dry. “Fuck yeah…”

Slowly, Penny crawled up the bed towards him, her heavy breasts swaying with each movement. She knelt beside him and dragged a painted nail along his jaw. “What would you do,” she murmured, “if I let you fuck me?”

Jack swallowed hard. “Penny, we can’t-”

She cut him off with a finger across his lips. “Shh. I know we shouldn’t, but… I want you so fucking bad right now.”

Penny deftly unzipped his jeans and reached inside to stroke the straining bulge she found there. Jack moaned and arched into her touch. She made quick work of freeing his thick, veiny cock from his boxers.

“Oh my god,” Penny breathed, wrapping her fingers around his throbbing shaft. “You’re so big.”

Jack bucked his hips, chasing more friction. “All for you, sweetheart.”

She stroked him faster, feeling him leak all over her knuckles. “Mmm… So hard, already. And so eager.”

Penny scooted down his body and took his cock into her mouth without warning, swallowing him down to the root in one smooth motion. Jack yelled in pleasure, fisting the sheets as she began to suck him like her life depended on it.

She bobbed on his cock, her plush lips stretched wide around his girth, drool leaking from the corners of her mouth to slick the way. Jack’s fingers tangled in her hair, his hips rolling up to meet her hungry mouth. “Oh fuck,” he panted. “Your mouth… Jesus Fuck, Penny…”

She gripped the base of his shaft and pumped in time with her bobbing, swirling her tongue around the leaking head on the upstroke. She looked up at him through her lashes, his stepbrother’s cock hilted in her pretty mouth, and whimpered around him.

Jack could feel his release building embarrassingly fast. “Baby, I’m gonna cum if you keep that up-”

Penny popped off his cock with a wet squelch and shimmied up his body to straddle his hips again. She reached between them and, with a little shift, positioned his cockhead at her dripping entrance.

“Cum for me,” she breathed, sinking down onto his shaft. They groaned in unison as Jack’s thick cock spread Penny’s tight little cunt wide and hilted inside of her. “Cum in your naughty stepsister’s pussy…”

Jack lost all restraint. He gripped her hips bruisingly hard and began to rut up into her, fucking her with short, hard bursts. Penny shrieked in ecstasy as he ravaged her needy hole. “Ye-yes!” she stammered, slamming her hips down to meet his thrusts. “Oh fuck, oh fuck, right there, yes!”

The lewd squelch of her soaked cunt being pounded full of cock mixed with their moans and the creaking of the mattress. Jack could feel his climactic pressure building at the base of his spine with alarming speed, spurred on by the exquisite grip of Penny’s fluttering walls around his pistoning cock. “I’m gonna cum,” he grunted. “I’m gonna fucking cum!”

“Do it!” Penny sobbed, nails raking down his chest. “Fill me up, baby! I want to feel you cum in me!”

Jack slammed up into her one last time and with a strangled cry, erupted inside her fluttering heat. Jet after jet of thick, potent cum painted Penny’s insides and she wailed, clenching down as she came apart on his cock. Her vision went white and her body shuddered with the force of her climax.

They collapsed together, panting. Jack’s softening cock slipped from Penny’s dripping cunt with a wet plop, followed by a thick trickle of their combined release. Penny rolled off of him with a satisfied sigh and snuggled into his side, resting her head on his heaving chest.

“So,” she mumbled after a long moment, “you gonna be staying here a while?”

Jack’s arm tightened around her. “Fuck yeah I am. I’m never gonna miss a chance to fuck this hot little cunt again.”

Penny preened under his praise and rubbed her messy slit with teasing fingers. “Mmm… good boy. We are gonna have sooo much fun together…”